How a Few Can Impact the Greater Good

This morning (9/11/2023) in the Wired Start weekly newsletter, an article was shared regarding the enforcement of tight restrictions on short-term rentals in New York City (NYC). Local Law 18 is the regulation being enforced that is all but shutting down short term rentals in NYC. This is one of the considerations you must contemplate when deciding to invest in short-term rentals, regulations can happen anywhere.

Here are some of the stipulations of the new regulation:

  • Hosts must register with the city
  • Only those who live in the unit can rent the unit – no more arbitrage
  • Hosts must be local during rentals
  • Only 2 guests during a rental
  • just to name a few ………

The city has really come down hard on the industry to combat the few those that abused what became a way for honest hosts to find a way to make ends meet in an expensive city. It also impacts those families that would not otherwise be able to afford to bring the family to the city for a sightseeing experience and vacation. Hotels and meals are expensive for a family and the short-term rental option provided all the comforts of home with kitchens to manage the cost of the vacation.

Dallas banned STRs (short-term rentals) in single family zoned areas on June 15th, 2023. Much of the reasoning is due to regulations and taxes. STRs fall closely in line with the hospitality industry and until now, have had little to no regulation.

The affordability of housing and vacations in the Northern Virgina (NVA) area have also driven investors to seek short-term rental options and “house hacking” (renting by the room instead of by the unit) to assist in making ends meet. There are investors that have seized the opportunity and unfortunately, guests / tenants take advantage of the situation impacting themselves and the landlords / hosts.

I am an agent investor with a lot I plan to build a small home to use personally, as well as rent short term when I’m not there. My brother already does this with his vacation home and short-term rentals were a topic of conversation with our new Home Owners Association (HOA) this past month. Again, it is the few that take the party too far, impacting those around them without thought that will drive any new regulations. We work to vet the guests as best as we can, but there is never a perfect solution. Fortunately for us, the HOA isn’t looking to develop harsh restrictions at this time. The only request was to have availability to the home owner hosting the short-term rentals so that the longer term residents have a course of action when guests become out of hand.


Airbnb host ~66 million guests a year looking for low cost options to experience location with the comforts of home. In 2022 alone, short-term rental listings accounted for ~$85 million in NYC. The city’s new regulations illustrate how the actions of a few can cause local governments to effectively stamp out short-term rentals overnight! NYC is just one of many cities around the world trying to control the ill effects that short-term rentals can bring. This is a two edged sword, by stamping out the short-term rental market, the vacation revenue that came with it also dries up.

Read the full story here.


As always . . .

Be sure to check out the:

Don’t forget the Home Buying and Selling Guides !

Never miss an issue by subscribing and I look forward to speaking with  you soon!

Michele Hudnall

About the Author

In the vast tapestry of Northern Virginia, Michele's roots run deep, with an unyielding passion to help her clients make smart moves. This region is a sprawling masterpiece, each corner radiating a unique personality that caters to diverse lifestyles. Michele's unwavering mission is to delve into the essence of her clients' aspirations, meticulously curating the perfect match between their dreams and the vibrant tapestry of Northern Virginia, even as lifestyles evolve and dreams take new forms. 

Armed with a formidable arsenal of market analysis, strategic prowess, and unrivaled consulting expertise, Michele empowers her clients to navigate the ever-shifting currents of the real estate landscape. She unveils the intricate dynamics and fierce competition that shape the market, providing her clients with a profound understanding that fuels their success. While the emotional tides of property transactions can easily sway hearts, Michele stands unwavering as the guardian of her clients' best interests, ensuring they relish every precious moment along the way.

Michele has forged an alliance with the industry's trailblazers, joining forces with Real Broker, LLC, a groundbreaking startup that challenges the very fabric of conventional practices. With an expanding network of exceptional agents nationwide, armed with cutting-edge resources, Michele remains at the vanguard of the evolving real estate industry, poised to transform dreams into concrete reality. 

Discover the unparalleled service, the unwavering commitment, and the magnetic spirit that will guide you towards finding not just a home, but a sanctuary where dreams flourish. 

Are you ready to unlock the door to your NVA destiny?